This Nearly Was Mine (Broadway Musical/S/South Pacific)
"Nice, but where is the intro and the segue? "

Defying Gravity (Broadway Musical/W/Wicked)
"Hey, great job! Your attention to orchestration is astounding. Was this done purely by aural dictation or were you aided by a score of some sort? Only critism, maybe you should reconsider the instrument used for the vocal line. The instrument used is really unflattering to what is otherwise a detail..."

Etude No. 3 in E Major (Tristesse), Opus 10 No.3, Lento, ma non troppo (Classical & Neo-Classical/C/Chopin, Frederic/Etudes)
"I was sitting with my daughter after a TV show we watched. The next show, Smallville, came on with this tune playing. I stopped in mid-sentence. It was a tune I had been searching for - for years. I first heard it when I was 21 but never found a way to identify it. I was totally unfamiliar with..."

Hello (Rock & Pop/E/Evanescence)
"The Piano part is wrong"

Prima Donna (Broadway Musical/P/Phantom of the Opera)
"Ptima Donna Was great in the movie but this dosn't even sound like it. It allmost soulds like it breathed in too much helium and is going to burst!!!!"