Masquerade / Why So Silent? (Broadway Musical/P/Phantom of the Opera)
"Or did you just listen to it? Wherever it came from this is fantastic?"

Lady Willpower (Rock & Pop/G/Gary Puckett)
"Great rendition of a super old song"

So Sick (Hip-Hop/N/Ne-Yo)
"It's pretty good, but it would be better if it was the complete song"

Medley (Themes/Movie Themes/P/Pirates of the Caribbean)
"yes"

Kiss (Rock & Pop/P/Prince)
"The worst rendition I've ever heard... it's truly horrible."